Short Answer
There is no single universally best shingle. Selection should consider architectural appearance, budget, climate, wind requirements, algae resistance, warranty, manufacturer system, roof design, and installation requirements.
Detailed Explanation
The 'best' shingle depends on your specific situation. A home on the Jersey Shore needs a shingle with high wind ratings and algae resistance. A home in a shaded wooded area may benefit from algae resistance. A home in an open, windy area needs enhanced wind ratings. Budget plays a role — but the cheapest shingle isn't always the best value if it doesn't meet your home's exposure requirements. The best approach is to discuss your home's specific conditions with a contractor who can recommend the right product rather than defaulting to whatever the contractor prefers to sell.
Why It Matters
Choosing a shingle based on price or appearance alone, without considering performance requirements for your specific home, can lead to premature failure.
Questions to Ask Your Contractor
- ?What wind rating does my home need?
- ?Do I need algae resistance for my area?
- ?What warranty comes with this shingle?
- ?Is this shingle part of a complete manufacturer system?